So, I hear there’s a debate about whether or not this book titled Speak by Laurie Halse Anderson should be banned. Apparently, a gentleman by the name of Wesley Scroggins feels that there are some issues addressed in the book which many should find offensive. Topics such as dysfunctional families and teenage sex are topics to which our children shouldn’t be exposed. Nor is the topic of rape. You may read what Mr. Scroggins says HERE.
Well, as the parent of three children, I can only agree…dysfunctional families are something no child should ever know. Teenage sex is something no parent should ever have to acknowledge. In a perfect world, we wouldn’t have to. Children would be taken care of and loved as they deserve. Our teens would be more careful with themselves, and not take chances with their futures and their lives. However, as a parent of two teens, I can say for fact that all I can do is raise them right and teach them what they need to know to survive. Because since I’m not locking them in a bubble in our house for the rest of their lives, the outside world will impact and influence my children.
I view it as my responsibility as a parent to know what my children are reading. My blog partner and I recently had a conversation wherein she expressed surprise that I read ALL of the books that are purchased or given to my children before they do. I have requested that their teachers tell me what books will be read so I can read those, as well. Christin was surprised by this, as her reading choices were never questioned as a child. Neither were mine. Reading was encouraged, and I was NEVER told I couldn't read a book. But I want to know what my children are reading so that I can discuss with them the topics that need discussion. This is the answer to books with uncomfortable topics...individual parental choices about whether the topic is appropriate for your child. Discussing the controversial topic with your child. Banning of books is NEVER the answer.
On the topic of rape, I have a very different opinion, however. I COMPLETELY agree with Mr. Scroggins…no child should ever know this. My thirteen-year-old self included.
I was raped when I was thirteen, by a friend of our family. It happened in an era and in an area where to publicly acknowledge its occurrence by pressing charges against the ADULT who raped me would’ve brought shame upon my whole family. So, instead my mother packed us up and moved us out of state. We left. Ran. I was a child whose mama tucked her tail between her legs and left the area. The only thought I had was that I’d never have to see him again.
I didn’t think about the nightmares which I would have, and still occasionally suffer. I didn’t think about wanting to have a boyfriend. I didn’t think about ever wanting to get married and have children. And I didn’t think about how hard any of that would be without ever having acknowledged that the rape had occurred. My family knew. I knew.
But the only counseling I received as a child was while hospitalized for attempting suicide four months after the rape. The doctor reviewing my case learned the reason why I attempted suicide...learned of the shame and guilt I felt for my mother having to give up her job and leave her family to move halfway across the country with me. Learned how I couldn't make friends at my new school because I felt like the fact that I was damaged was tattooed on my forehead. Learned that I couldn't be boy crazy like other girls my age because I couldn't stand for a boy to be close enough to me to talk to me. Learned that I was a problem for my male teachers, that I would break down into tears and shake like a leaf when they would single me out in any way. I never saw that doctor again.
No one knew any of this...because I wasn't allowed to speak.
I was thirty-one years old before I obtained counseling for my rape. And only then because the rape of a close family member brought every single one of my nightmares back. It was my husband, not always the most empathic person, who suggested I speak to someone about my rape. I truly believe he did so out of love. But I also think he was tired of waking to me screaming, and to me hitting him when he'd make the mistake of trying to soothe me while I was locked in the clutches of a nightmare.
So, Mr. Scroggins…I’m sorry. But NO ONE gets to tell me to be quiet anymore. I carry the scars that say I have the right to address this topic. I will speak.
Read what Laurie Halse Anderson has to say about this topic HERE.
I'm so sorry you had to go through that, but it's so, so inspiring that you had the guts to speak out and let others who have suffered similarly that there IS a way to overcome these horrible experiences. Thanks for having the courage to take a stand!
ReplyDeleteNatalie:
ReplyDeleteThank you for reading my post. I don't feel inspiring or brave...and after I wrote the post I felt very, very sick. But I agree...it's a topic that must be brought to light. Thanks for being part of that.
Louise
Between the Covers
You are in my prayers and thank you for speaking out. I work as a secretary for children of abuse and neglect and it is heartbreaking everyday to see what people do to children. Things that will mold them for life...scars that never go away.
ReplyDeleteLou- whether you feel it or not, you are brave and inspiring. Thank you for being strong enough to speak, strong enough to share your story. We love you. (((Hugs)))
ReplyDeleteKate (ava1981)
A Reader's Ramblings
Heartbreaking. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteLou, I love you more than words can say and I am so proud of you for speaking up about this. I think it's so important for young readers to know that they are not alone and it upsets me so much that so many of them feel like they have no voice.
ReplyDeleteThank you for posting this!
Regina, Kate, Richard and Cindy:
ReplyDeleteThank you all for reading and commenting. Hopefully, knowing this happened will help someone, somewhere.
Louise
Between the Covers
Lou:
ReplyDeleteI agree with those above who say you are brave. You absolutely are brave because you refuse to remain silent about one of the most horrific parts of your life. You give voice to something that clearly has has a huge impact on your life, and by giving voice to your history, by sharing you story, you set an amazing example for other women, other young women, and other girls who may, unfortunately, experience what you experienced. So thank you for sharing your history with us. You are brave, and it takes great courage to share something so painful with the world.
And thank you for being the kind of parent who lives in the real world.
I love you, Lou! Thank you for being you!
(((hugs)))
ReplyDeleteYour bravery is humbling. Your example as a parent is priceless. Thank you.
You are very brave and I admire you for telling this story. Speaking is part of healing. I am so sorry you went through all of that alone.
ReplyDeleteMy husband came back from Vietnam with PTSD when it wasn't supposed to exist, so I know what it is like to live with someone who has it. I write about recovering from PTSD and have a website with free articles at www.patiencepress.com.
Thanks for a very moving post.
Lou, you are amazing. There is nothing I could say that hasn't already been say. I am so proud of you for finding the courage to speak out, to speak up, and to speak loudly. ((hugs))
ReplyDeleteSo sorry to hear what happened to you. Thank you for having the courage to speak up and share your story. You're helping to destroy the taboos that stupid, ignorant people would prefer to keep in place to preserve their peace of mind.
ReplyDeleteOK..WOW..I am proud you can stand up and take all that back hopefully you can continue to squash it, it will never go away, since it is part of who you are, but taking back control is impressive.
ReplyDelete-CCG
Lou Lou....
ReplyDeleteThank you for posting this. For you and for everyone that has *ever* had to go through this and continue to live it daily.
Thank you!
Lou.
ReplyDeleteI don't want to make light of this topic at all, but I don't really know what else to say... so I hope to put a smile on your face by saying "HOLLA!" and to tell you that I think by saying what has happened to you, you are one of the bravest people I know, and that I think it will encourage others to Speak Loudly too.
I'm so sorry you had to go through this.
Lots of love xxx
This is very powerful and thanks for being brave enough to speak up on this topic.
ReplyDeleteMy sweet Lou...how I love you. Never lose your voice and always Speak Loudly!
ReplyDeleteBeautifully said. I also agree with you on reading books before letting you let your children read them. There are far too many ‘YA’ books these days that are completely unsuitable and books that I would never personally allow my children to read.
ReplyDeleteYou're amazing and brave and I admire you for not being silent, honestly. It takes a lot of courage to speak about it out loud.
ReplyDeleteWith all my love,
Wicked Leel